Profilul lui Carli Fisser | Binance Square

·

--

🕌 Is Binance Square Write-to-Earn Commission Reward Halal? 🔴 Short Answer (Clear & Direct): No — this commission-based reward is NOT halal. It is haram due to how the commission is generated. 🔍 Why This Commission Is Haram (Important) From the image, the key words are: “Earn up to 50% commission rewards” This is NOT a salary for writing. This is an affiliate-style commission. Here’s the issue 👇 ❌ 1️⃣ Commission comes from users’ trading activity Your earnings depend on: Users trading on Binance Trading fees generated by them 🚨 Binance’s trading ecosystem heavily includes: Futures Margin Leverage Interest-based products ➡️ You are earning from haram transactions, even if you personally don’t trade futures. ❌ 2️⃣ This is not “wages for work” (ujrah) In halal income: You work → fixed agreed payment Here: You write → reward depends on others trading Income is uncertain, variable, and performance-based ➡️ This introduces gharar (uncertainty). ❌ 3️⃣ You are promoting haram activities indirectly Even if you write “educational” content: Your commission grows when users trade Many will trade leverage/futures You benefit from that activity 📌 In Islam: Indirect benefit from haram is also haram. 🧠 Islamic Principle Applied “When halal and haram are mixed, the haram dominates.” This commission: Is tied to haram revenue streams Lacks transparency of source ➡️ Falls clearly into haram, not just doubtful. ✅ What WOULD Be Halal Instead? ✔️ Fixed payment for writing (salary/freelance) ✔️ Content work paid in fiat or crypto as wages ✔️ No link to trading volume or commissions ✔️ Independent crypto education platforms 🟢 Final Ruling (Straightforward) Binance Square Write-to-Earn COMMISSION ❌ HARAM Not just doubtful — clearly impermissible Best to avoid for barakah and peace of heart 🌙 One-Line Summary If your income increases when others trade leverage or futures, that income is not halal — even if you only “write.”

🕌 Is Binance Square Write-to-Earn Commission Reward Halal?
🔴 Short Answer (Clear & Direct):
No — this commission-based reward is NOT halal.
It is haram due to how the commission is generated.
🔍 Why This Commission Is Haram (Important)
From the image, the key words are:
“Earn up to 50% commission rewards”
This is NOT a salary for writing.
This is an affiliate-style commission.
Here’s the issue 👇
❌ 1️⃣ Commission comes from users’ trading activity
Your earnings depend on:
Users trading on Binance
Trading fees generated by them
🚨 Binance’s trading ecosystem heavily includes:
Futures
Margin
Leverage
Interest-based products
➡️ You are earning from haram transactions, even if you personally don’t trade futures.
❌ 2️⃣ This is not “wages for work” (ujrah)
In halal income:
You work → fixed agreed payment
Here:
You write → reward depends on others trading
Income is uncertain, variable, and performance-based ➡️ This introduces gharar (uncertainty).
❌ 3️⃣ You are promoting haram activities indirectly
Even if you write “educational” content:
Your commission grows when users trade
Many will trade leverage/futures
You benefit from that activity
📌 In Islam:
Indirect benefit from haram is also haram.
🧠 Islamic Principle Applied
“When halal and haram are mixed, the haram dominates.”
This commission:
Is tied to haram revenue streams
Lacks transparency of source ➡️ Falls clearly into haram, not just doubtful.
✅ What WOULD Be Halal Instead?
✔️ Fixed payment for writing (salary/freelance)
✔️ Content work paid in fiat or crypto as wages
✔️ No link to trading volume or commissions
✔️ Independent crypto education platforms
🟢 Final Ruling (Straightforward)
Binance Square Write-to-Earn COMMISSION ❌ HARAM
Not just doubtful — clearly impermissible
Best to avoid for barakah and peace of heart
🌙 One-Line Summary
If your income increases when others trade leverage or futures, that income is not halal — even if you only “write.”

Carli Fisser

Subiecte în tendințe

Ultimele știri